CITATION VALIDATION DETAILED REPORT
================================================================================

BOOK: Christmas Miracles
------------------------------------------------------------
✅ Reason 1: PASS (100%)

✅ Reason 2: PASS (100%)

✅ Reason 3: PASS (95%)

✅ Reason 4: PASS (100%)


BOOK: Christmas 101
------------------------------------------------------------
✅ Reason 1: PASS (100%)

✅ Reason 2: PASS (100%)

✅ Reason 3: PASS (100%)

✅ Reason 4: PASS (100%)


BOOK: The Official Guide to Christmas in the South
------------------------------------------------------------
✅ Reason 1: PASS (100%)

✅ Reason 2: PASS (100%)

✅ Reason 3: PASS (100%)

✅ Reason 4: PASS (100%)


BOOK: The First Christmas
------------------------------------------------------------
✅ Reason 1: PASS (100%)

✅ Reason 2: PASS (100%)

✅ Reason 3: PASS (100%)

✅ Reason 4: PASS (100%)


BOOK: Christmas Cake
------------------------------------------------------------
✅ Reason 1: PASS (100%)

✅ Reason 2: PASS (100%)

✅ Reason 3: PASS (100%)

✅ Reason 4: PASS (100%)


SUMMARY: 20/20 reasons passed (100.0%)
OVERALL STATUS: PASS

Citation Validation Summary: 20/20 passed

PER-BOOK AI VALIDATION REPORT - Query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
================================================================================

OVERALL RELEVANCE SCORE: 85%
STATUS: PASS
BOOKS ANALYZED: 5

BOOK 1: "Christmas Miracles"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 95%

SECTION SCORES:
  Author Information: 100% - The authors are clearly and correctly identified.
  Publishing Date: 100% - The publishing date is provided and seems accurate and appropriate for the book's content.
  Why Match Explanations: 90% - The explanations strongly justify the book's relevance, clearly stating it contains true stories about Christmas. The use of internal tags like '(manuscript)' is slightly distracting but doesn't harm the clarity.
  Relevance Scores: 95% - The 98% score is very well-justified. The 'Gap' explanation correctly points out the specific focus on miracles as the reason it's not a 100% match for all aspects of Christmas, showing a nuanced understanding.

DETAILED FEEDBACK:
  • This is an excellent recommendation for the query, providing a specific type of Christmas book (inspirational stories).
  • All sections are well-populated and the reasoning is sound.

IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
  • For a cleaner presentation, remove internal-facing tags like '(manuscript)' and '(metadata)' from the user-facing explanation.

================================================================================

BOOK 2: "Christmas 101"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 95%

SECTION SCORES:
  Author Information: 100% - The author is correctly identified.
  Publishing Date: 100% - The publishing date is provided and is appropriate for a holiday guide book.
  Why Match Explanations: 95% - The explanations are very effective, describing the book as a practical guide for Christmas entertaining, cooking, and history. The connection to the query is explicit and strong.
  Relevance Scores: 95% - The 97% score and its justification are excellent. The 'Gap' correctly identifies that the focus on cooking and entertaining might not suit all readers, which perfectly explains the slight deduction from 100%.

DETAILED FEEDBACK:
  • A highly relevant and practical suggestion that addresses a common aspect of the Christmas holiday.
  • The justification for the relevance score is particularly strong and insightful.

IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
  • No major improvements needed for this entry; it is a model of a good recommendation.

================================================================================

BOOK 3: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 75%

SECTION SCORES:
  Author Information: 0% - Author information is missing from the provided response text.
  Publishing Date: 0% - Publishing date is missing from the provided response text.
  Why Match Explanations: 90% - The explanations are clear and humorous, effectively conveying the book's specific focus on Christmas from a Southern cultural perspective. The relevance is well-established.
  Relevance Scores: 95% - The 95% score is perfectly justified. The 'Gap' explanation correctly pinpoints the niche, regional focus as the reason for the score, which is a very accurate assessment.

DETAILED FEEDBACK:
  • The recommendation itself is a good, niche choice for the query.
  • The analysis in the 'Why Match' and 'Relevance Scores' sections is excellent.
  • However, the entry is critically incomplete as it lacks author and publication date information in the provided text.

IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
  • Ensure that essential metadata like Author and Publishing Date are always included for every book.

================================================================================

BOOK 4: "The First Christmas"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 80%

SECTION SCORES:
  Author Information: 0% - Author information is missing from the provided response text.
  Publishing Date: 0% - Publishing date is missing from the provided response text.
  Why Match Explanations: 95% - The explanations are outstanding, clearly defining the book's focus on the historical and religious origins of Christmas. It directly connects the book's content to the core of the holiday.
  Relevance Scores: 95% - The justification for the 94% score is precise and accurate. It correctly identifies that the deep religious/historical focus may not align with users seeking festive or cultural content.

DETAILED FEEDBACK:
  • This is a highly relevant book that addresses the foundational story of Christmas.
  • The quality of the justification for its relevance and score is very high.
  • The entry's overall quality is severely hampered by the missing author and publishing date.

IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
  • Crucial metadata such as Author and Publishing Date must be consistently provided for all recommended books.

================================================================================

BOOK 5: "Christmas Cake"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 80%

SECTION SCORES:
  Author Information: 0% - Author information is missing from the provided response text.
  Publishing Date: 0% - Publishing date is missing from the provided response text.
  Why Match Explanations: 90% - The explanation does a good job of positioning this fiction novel as a Christmas book, highlighting its holiday setting and a climax around Christmas Eve.
  Relevance Scores: 95% - The 93% score is supported by an excellent justification. The 'Gap' correctly explains the nuance that the book uses Christmas as a setting rather than being solely about the holiday itself, which is a key distinction.

DETAILED FEEDBACK:
  • This is a good example of including a relevant fiction title for a holiday-themed query.
  • The analysis clearly explains why it's a match and why it's not rated higher.
  • The entry is incomplete due to missing author and publication information.

IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
  • Ensure that all book entries are complete with author and publication date to be fully useful to the user.

================================================================================

SUMMARY FEEDBACK:
----------------------------------------
• The response provides an excellent and diverse selection of books that interpret the broad query 'books on christmas' in different, valid ways (inspirational, practical, cultural, historical, fictional).
• The 'Why Match' and 'Relevance Score' justifications are a major strength, showing sophisticated, nuanced reasoning for each selection.
• The provided text for the last three books is incomplete, which significantly degrades the quality of those specific recommendations.

OVERALL IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
----------------------------------------
• The highest priority is to ensure data integrity. All recommended books must have complete metadata, including author and publishing date.
• Consider removing internal system tags like '(manuscript)' and '(metadata)' from the final user-facing text for a more polished and professional appearance.

=== SCENARIO LOGS: Book Genie Response Validation with Citation Verification ===
[2:40:07 PM] Navigating to Creative Workspace login page
[2:40:11 PM] Homepage visibility: false
[2:40:11 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:11 PM] ℹ️ Preparing to type query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:11 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for chat input to be visible
[2:40:13 PM] ℹ️ Clearing chat input
[2:40:13 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:14 PM] ℹ️ Pressing Enter to submit query
[2:40:15 PM] ✅ Query submitted successfully: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:15 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for AI to complete thinking...
[2:40:15 PM] 📋 WAITING FOR AI RESPONSE
[2:40:15 PM] ℹ️ Looking for AI thinking indicator...
[2:40:15 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to appear (max 2 minutes)
[2:40:17 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking indicator appeared - AI is processing the request
[2:40:17 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to disappear (max 5 minutes)
[2:40:31 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking completed - Response should be ready
[2:40:31 PM] ℹ️ Allowing additional time for response rendering
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ AI response wait process completed
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Validating response for query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:34 PM] 📋 VALIDATING RESPONSE FOR QUERY: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Locating the latest response in chat
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for response to be visible (max 30 seconds)
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ Response received - Length: 6113 characters
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Response preview: Watch Me WorkInterpreting context for your query...Retrieving Relevant Books for 'books with a Chris...
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Extracting book data from response...
[2:40:34 PM] 📋 EXTRACTING BOOK DATA FROM RESPONSE
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Locating BookGenie response container
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from response
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ HTML content extracted - Length: 44025 characters
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract book data
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED 5 BOOKS
[2:40:34 PM] 📋 EXTRACTED BOOKS SUMMARY
[2:40:34 PM] 📚 1. "Christmas Miracles" - Score: 98%%
[2:40:34 PM] 📚 2. "Christmas 101" - Score: 97%%
[2:40:34 PM] 📚 3. "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - Score: 95%%
[2:40:34 PM] 📚 4. "The First Christmas" - Score: 94%%
[2:40:34 PM] 📚 5. "Christmas Cake" - Score: 93%%
[2:40:34 PM] 📊 Total books extracted: 5
[2:40:34 PM] 📊 Average relevance score: 95%
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ Extracted 5 books from response
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Saving 5 books to Excel file: test_results/suggest_5_books_on_christmas.xlsx
[2:40:34 PM] 📋 SAVING BOOKS TO EXCEL FILE
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Target file path: test_results/suggest_5_books_on_christmas.xlsx
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Exporting 5 books to Excel format
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ Book data saved to: test_results/suggest_5_books_on_christmas.xlsx
[2:40:34 PM] 📊 File verified - Size: 20.04 KB
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✓ Excel file creation verified successfully
[2:40:34 PM] 📋 STARTING INDIVIDUAL BOOK VALIDATION (5 books) for query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:34 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 1: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "Christmas Miracles" vs expected: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 98% vs expected: 98%
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 98% (expected 98%)
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 4 vs expected 4
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 4 points (expected 4)
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 1 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Book 1 validation completed
[2:40:34 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 2: "Christmas 101"
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "Christmas 101" vs expected: "Christmas 101"
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "Christmas 101"
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 97% vs expected: 97%
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 97% (expected 97%)
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 4 vs expected 4
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 4 points (expected 4)
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 2 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Book 2 validation completed
[2:40:34 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 3: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" vs expected: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 95% vs expected: 95%
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 95% (expected 95%)
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 4 vs expected 4
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 4 points (expected 4)
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 3 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Book 3 validation completed
[2:40:34 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 4: "The First Christmas"
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "The First Christmas" vs expected: "The First Christmas"
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "The First Christmas"
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 94% vs expected: 94%
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 94% (expected 94%)
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 4 vs expected 4
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 4 points (expected 4)
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 4 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Book 4 validation completed
[2:40:34 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 5: "Christmas Cake"
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "Christmas Cake" vs expected: "Christmas Cake"
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "Christmas Cake"
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 93% vs expected: 93%
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 93% (expected 93%)
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 4 vs expected 4
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 4 points (expected 4)
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 5 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Book 5 validation completed
[2:40:34 PM] 📊 VALIDATION SUMMARY: 5/5 books passed
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ ALL BOOKS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY!
[2:40:34 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING REASON-CITATION MATCHES
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Starting citation validation process...
[2:40:34 PM] 📋 🚀 STARTING COMPLETE CITATION VALIDATION WORKFLOW
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Step 1: Extracting books from AI response
[2:40:34 PM] 📋 EXTRACTING BOOK DATA FROM RESPONSE
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Locating BookGenie response container
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from response
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ HTML content extracted - Length: 44025 characters
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract book data
[2:40:34 PM] ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED 5 BOOKS
[2:40:34 PM] 📋 EXTRACTED BOOKS SUMMARY
[2:40:34 PM] 📚 1. "Christmas Miracles" - Score: 98%%
[2:40:34 PM] 📚 2. "Christmas 101" - Score: 97%%
[2:40:34 PM] 📚 3. "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - Score: 95%%
[2:40:34 PM] 📚 4. "The First Christmas" - Score: 94%%
[2:40:34 PM] 📚 5. "Christmas Cake" - Score: 93%%
[2:40:34 PM] 📊 Total books extracted: 5
[2:40:34 PM] 📊 Average relevance score: 95%
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Step 2: Extracting citation texts from book elements
[2:40:34 PM] 📋 📚 EXTRACTING CITATION TEXTS FROM BOOK ELEMENTS
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Step 1: Waiting for main book section
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Found 16 total accordion sections
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "1. Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "2. Christmas 101"
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "3. The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "4. The First Christmas"
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "5. Christmas Cake"
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Processing 5 individual book sections
[2:40:34 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 1: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:37 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:37 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:40 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:40 PM] ℹ️ Found 4 citation buttons for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:40 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/4 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:40 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 1 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:41 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 1
[2:40:43 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): "Christmas Miracles" explores the profound impact of resilience and transformative human connection...
[2:40:43 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 1
[2:40:45 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 1 closed successfully
[2:40:45 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 99)
[2:40:45 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/4 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:45 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 2 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:46 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 2
[2:40:48 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Christmas season, even the most cynical hearts become open to wondrous occurrences...
[2:40:48 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 2
[2:40:49 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 2 closed successfully
[2:40:49 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 82)
[2:40:49 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/4 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:49 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 3 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:50 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 3
[2:40:52 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): This collection aims to present true, heartwarming stories of such miraculous events, highlighting i...
[2:40:52 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 3
[2:40:54 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 3 closed successfully
[2:40:54 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 302)
[2:40:54 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 4/4 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:54 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 4 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:55 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 4
[2:40:57 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Christmas miracles...
[2:40:57 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 4
[2:40:58 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 4 closed successfully
[2:40:58 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 4 extracted successfully (length: 18)
[2:40:58 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:41:00 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:41:00 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "Christmas Miracles" - 4 citations extracted
[2:41:00 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 2: "Christmas 101"
[2:41:00 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "Christmas 101"
[2:41:03 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "Christmas 101"
[2:41:03 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "Christmas 101"
[2:41:06 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "Christmas 101"
[2:41:06 PM] ℹ️ Found 4 citation buttons for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:06 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/4 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:06 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 1 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:07 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 1
[2:41:09 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): "CHRISTMAS 101" honors the culinary legacy of Dick and Eleanor Rodgers, transforming their tradition...
[2:41:09 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 1
[2:41:11 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 1 closed successfully
[2:41:11 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 219)
[2:41:11 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/4 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:11 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 2 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:12 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 2
[2:41:14 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): the rich, global history of iconic treats like cookies and candy canes...
[2:41:14 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 2
[2:41:15 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 2 closed successfully
[2:41:15 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 70)
[2:41:15 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/4 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:15 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 3 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:16 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 3
[2:41:19 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): the art of crafting festive beverages...
[2:41:19 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 3
[2:41:20 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 3 closed successfully
[2:41:20 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 37)
[2:41:20 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 4/4 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:20 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 4 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:21 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 4
[2:41:23 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Christmas 101 is your go-to guide to make holiday planning simple, fun and festive...
[2:41:23 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 4
[2:41:25 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 4 closed successfully
[2:41:25 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 4 extracted successfully (length: 82)
[2:41:25 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "Christmas 101"
[2:41:26 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "Christmas 101"
[2:41:26 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "Christmas 101" - 4 citations extracted
[2:41:26 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 3: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:26 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:29 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:29 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:32 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:32 PM] ℹ️ Found 4 citation buttons for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:32 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/4 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:32 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 1 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:33 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 1
[2:41:35 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): charming, humorous guide, anyone can learn how to deck the halls, Southern style...
[2:41:35 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 1
[2:41:37 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 1 closed successfully
[2:41:37 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 80)
[2:41:37 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/4 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:37 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 2 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:38 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 2
[2:41:40 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): The book humorously ponders why the Wise Men overlooked this essential Southern offering, emphasizin...
[2:41:40 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 2
[2:41:42 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 2 closed successfully
[2:41:42 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 212)
[2:41:42 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/4 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:42 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 3 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:43 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 3
[2:41:45 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Perfect for a true Southerner's coffee table or an imposter's survival guide...
[2:41:45 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 3
[2:41:46 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 3 closed successfully
[2:41:46 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 76)
[2:41:46 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 4/4 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:46 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 4 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:47 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 4
[2:41:49 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): navigating through the holiday season...
[2:41:49 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 4
[2:41:51 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 4 closed successfully
[2:41:51 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 4 extracted successfully (length: 37)
[2:41:51 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:52 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:52 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - 4 citations extracted
[2:41:52 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 4: "The First Christmas"
[2:41:52 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "The First Christmas"
[2:41:56 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "The First Christmas"
[2:41:56 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "The First Christmas"
[2:41:59 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "The First Christmas"
[2:41:59 PM] ℹ️ Found 4 citation buttons for "The First Christmas"
[2:41:59 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/4 for "The First Christmas"
[2:41:59 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 1 for "The First Christmas"
[2:42:00 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 1
[2:42:02 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): the stories of Jesus’s birth...
[2:42:02 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 1
[2:42:03 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 1 closed successfully
[2:42:03 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 28)
[2:42:03 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/4 for "The First Christmas"
[2:42:03 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 2 for "The First Christmas"
[2:42:04 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 2
[2:42:06 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): stories of Jesus’s birth are the foundation of the world’s most widely observed holiday...
[2:42:06 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 2
[2:42:08 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 2 closed successfully
[2:42:08 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 87)
[2:42:08 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/4 for "The First Christmas"
[2:42:08 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 3 for "The First Christmas"
[2:42:09 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 3
[2:42:11 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): real Christmas story...
[2:42:11 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 3
[2:42:12 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 3 closed successfully
[2:42:12 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 20)
[2:42:12 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 4/4 for "The First Christmas"
[2:42:13 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 4 for "The First Christmas"
[2:42:14 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 4
[2:42:16 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): is about the beginning. Together, the stories of his birth and the stories of his last week are like...
[2:42:16 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 4
[2:42:17 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 4 closed successfully
[2:42:17 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 4 extracted successfully (length: 187)
[2:42:17 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "The First Christmas"
[2:42:19 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "The First Christmas"
[2:42:19 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "The First Christmas" - 4 citations extracted
[2:42:19 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 5: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:19 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:22 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:22 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:25 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:25 PM] ℹ️ Found 4 citation buttons for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:25 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/4 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:25 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 1 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:26 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 1
[2:42:28 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): a delightful read for the holidays...
[2:42:28 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 1
[2:42:29 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 1 closed successfully
[2:42:29 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 34)
[2:42:29 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/4 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:29 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 2 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:30 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 2
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): a heartwarming story that celebrates the close and lifelong bonds among women...
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 2
[2:42:34 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 2 closed successfully
[2:42:34 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 77)
[2:42:34 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/4 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:34 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 3 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:35 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 3
[2:42:37 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): small fictional Southern community as unforgettable as Jan Karon’s   Mitford...
[2:42:37 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 3
[2:42:39 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 3 closed successfully
[2:42:39 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 76)
[2:42:39 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 4/4 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:39 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 4 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:40 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 4
[2:42:42 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Christmas Eve...
[2:42:42 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 4
[2:42:43 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 4 closed successfully
[2:42:43 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 4 extracted successfully (length: 13)
[2:42:43 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:45 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:45 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "Christmas Cake" - 4 citations extracted
[2:42:45 PM] ✅ 🎉 Successfully extracted citations from 5 books
[2:42:45 PM] ℹ️ Step 3: Validating reason-citation matches
[2:42:45 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING REASON-CITATION MATCHES (80% THRESHOLD)
[2:42:45 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 4 reasons for: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:42:45 PM] ℹ️    Reason 1: Checking match...
[2:42:45 PM] ✅    ✅ "Christmas Miracles" - Reason 1: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:45 PM] ℹ️    Reason 2: Checking match...
[2:42:45 PM] ✅    ✅ "Christmas Miracles" - Reason 2: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:45 PM] ℹ️    Reason 3: Checking match...
[2:42:54 PM] ✅    ✅ "Christmas Miracles" - Reason 3: 95% match - PASS
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️    Reason 4: Checking match...
[2:42:54 PM] ✅    ✅ "Christmas Miracles" - Reason 4: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 4 reasons for: "Christmas 101"
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️    Reason 1: Checking match...
[2:42:54 PM] ✅    ✅ "Christmas 101" - Reason 1: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️    Reason 2: Checking match...
[2:42:54 PM] ✅    ✅ "Christmas 101" - Reason 2: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️    Reason 3: Checking match...
[2:42:54 PM] ✅    ✅ "Christmas 101" - Reason 3: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️    Reason 4: Checking match...
[2:42:54 PM] ✅    ✅ "Christmas 101" - Reason 4: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 4 reasons for: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️    Reason 1: Checking match...
[2:42:54 PM] ✅    ✅ "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - Reason 1: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️    Reason 2: Checking match...
[2:42:54 PM] ✅    ✅ "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - Reason 2: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️    Reason 3: Checking match...
[2:42:54 PM] ✅    ✅ "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - Reason 3: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️    Reason 4: Checking match...
[2:42:54 PM] ✅    ✅ "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - Reason 4: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 4 reasons for: "The First Christmas"
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️    Reason 1: Checking match...
[2:42:54 PM] ✅    ✅ "The First Christmas" - Reason 1: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️    Reason 2: Checking match...
[2:42:54 PM] ✅    ✅ "The First Christmas" - Reason 2: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️    Reason 3: Checking match...
[2:42:54 PM] ✅    ✅ "The First Christmas" - Reason 3: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️    Reason 4: Checking match...
[2:42:54 PM] ✅    ✅ "The First Christmas" - Reason 4: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 4 reasons for: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️    Reason 1: Checking match...
[2:42:54 PM] ✅    ✅ "Christmas Cake" - Reason 1: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️    Reason 2: Checking match...
[2:42:54 PM] ✅    ✅ "Christmas Cake" - Reason 2: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️    Reason 3: Checking match...
[2:42:54 PM] ✅    ✅ "Christmas Cake" - Reason 3: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️    Reason 4: Checking match...
[2:42:54 PM] ✅    ✅ "Christmas Cake" - Reason 4: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:54 PM] 📊 📊 CITATION VALIDATION SUMMARY: 20/20 passed (100.0%)
[2:42:54 PM] ✅ 🎉 REASON-CITATION VALIDATION: OVERALL PASSED
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️ Step 4: Generating detailed report
[2:42:54 PM] 📋 📋 GENERATING CITATION VALIDATION REPORT
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️ Report generated: 20/20 reasons passed
[2:42:54 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation workflow completed successfully
[2:42:54 PM] 📊 📈 OVERALL CITATION VALIDATION: 20/20 (100.0%)
[2:42:54 PM] ✅ ✅ REASON-CITATION VALIDATION: OVERALL PASSED
[2:42:54 PM] 📋 📋 GENERATING DETAILED CITATION VALIDATION REPORT
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️ Generating HTML citation validation report
[2:42:54 PM] ✅ Generated HTML report for 20 reasons
[2:42:54 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation HTML report generated and attached
[2:42:54 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation plain text report attached
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️ Checking database connectivity...
[2:42:54 PM] ✅ ✅ Database connected successfully
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️ Database path: /home/runner/work/HC_Epub_Automation/HC_Epub_Automation/tests/test_data/database.xlsx
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️ Total books: 5455
[2:42:54 PM] 📊 Database contains 5455 books
[2:42:54 PM] ✅ ✅ Database book count requirement met: 5455 >= 2020
[2:42:54 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING EXTRACTED BOOKS INDIVIDUALLY AGAINST DATABASE
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 1/5: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:42:54 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "Christmas Miracles" → "Christmas Miracles"
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 2/5: "Christmas 101"
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "Christmas 101"
[2:42:54 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "Christmas 101" → "Christmas 101"
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 3/5: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:42:54 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" → "He"
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 4/5: "The First Christmas"
[2:42:54 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "The First Christmas"
[2:42:55 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "The First Christmas" → "He"
[2:42:55 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 5/5: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:55 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:55 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "Christmas Cake" → "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:55 PM] 📊 INDIVIDUAL DATABASE VALIDATION SUMMARY: 5/5 books found in database
[2:42:55 PM] ✅ 🎉 ALL BOOKS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY AGAINST DATABASE!
[2:42:55 PM] 📋 🤖 VALIDATING RESPONSE RELEVANCE WITH GEMINI AI - PER BOOK ANALYSIS
[2:42:55 PM] ℹ️ Starting Gemini AI per-book relevance validation...
[2:42:55 PM] 📋 🤖 ANALYZING RESPONSE RELEVANCE WITH GEMINI AI - PER BOOK ANALYSIS
[2:42:55 PM] ℹ️ Starting Gemini AI analysis with retry logic...
[2:43:43 PM] 📊 Gemini AI Overall Relevance Score: 85%
[2:43:43 PM] 📊 Analyzed 5 books individually
[2:43:43 PM] ✅ ✅ GEMINI VALIDATION: Response is relevant to query (85%)
[2:43:43 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "Christmas Miracles" - Score: 95%
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Author Information: 100% - The authors are clearly and correctly identified.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Publishing Date: 100% - The publishing date is provided and seems accurate and appropriate for the book's content.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 90% - The explanations strongly justify the book's relevance, clearly stating it contains true stories about Christmas. The use of internal tags like '(manuscript)' is slightly distracting but doesn't harm the clarity.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 95% - The 98% score is very well-justified. The 'Gap' explanation correctly points out the specific focus on miracles as the reason it's not a 100% match for all aspects of Christmas, showing a nuanced understanding.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️    - For a cleaner presentation, remove internal-facing tags like '(manuscript)' and '(metadata)' from the user-facing explanation.
[2:43:43 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "Christmas 101" - Score: 95%
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Author Information: 100% - The author is correctly identified.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Publishing Date: 100% - The publishing date is provided and is appropriate for a holiday guide book.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 95% - The explanations are very effective, describing the book as a practical guide for Christmas entertaining, cooking, and history. The connection to the query is explicit and strong.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 95% - The 97% score and its justification are excellent. The 'Gap' correctly identifies that the focus on cooking and entertaining might not suit all readers, which perfectly explains the slight deduction from 100%.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️    - No major improvements needed for this entry; it is a model of a good recommendation.
[2:43:43 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - Score: 75%
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Author Information: 0% - Author information is missing from the provided response text.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Publishing Date: 0% - Publishing date is missing from the provided response text.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 90% - The explanations are clear and humorous, effectively conveying the book's specific focus on Christmas from a Southern cultural perspective. The relevance is well-established.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 95% - The 95% score is perfectly justified. The 'Gap' explanation correctly pinpoints the niche, regional focus as the reason for the score, which is a very accurate assessment.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️    - Ensure that essential metadata like Author and Publishing Date are always included for every book.
[2:43:43 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "The First Christmas" - Score: 80%
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Author Information: 0% - Author information is missing from the provided response text.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Publishing Date: 0% - Publishing date is missing from the provided response text.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 95% - The explanations are outstanding, clearly defining the book's focus on the historical and religious origins of Christmas. It directly connects the book's content to the core of the holiday.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 95% - The justification for the 94% score is precise and accurate. It correctly identifies that the deep religious/historical focus may not align with users seeking festive or cultural content.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️    - Crucial metadata such as Author and Publishing Date must be consistently provided for all recommended books.
[2:43:43 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "Christmas Cake" - Score: 80%
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Author Information: 0% - Author information is missing from the provided response text.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Publishing Date: 0% - Publishing date is missing from the provided response text.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 90% - The explanation does a good job of positioning this fiction novel as a Christmas book, highlighting its holiday setting and a climax around Christmas Eve.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 95% - The 93% score is supported by an excellent justification. The 'Gap' correctly explains the nuance that the book uses Christmas as a setting rather than being solely about the holiday itself, which is a key distinction.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️    - Ensure that all book entries are complete with author and publication date to be fully useful to the user.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️ 📊 SUMMARY FEEDBACK:
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️    • The response provides an excellent and diverse selection of books that interpret the broad query 'books on christmas' in different, valid ways (inspirational, practical, cultural, historical, fictional).
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️    • The 'Why Match' and 'Relevance Score' justifications are a major strength, showing sophisticated, nuanced reasoning for each selection.
[2:43:43 PM] ℹ️    • The provided text for the last three books is incomplete, which significantly degrades the quality of those specific recommendations.
[2:43:43 PM] ✅ ✅ GEMINI AI VALIDATION PASSED: 85% relevance score
=== END LOGS ===

CITATION VALIDATION DETAILED REPORT
================================================================================

BOOK: The Antiracist Kid
------------------------------------------------------------
✅ Reason 1: PASS (100%)

✅ Reason 2: PASS (100%)

✅ Reason 3: PASS (100%)


BOOK: Axel the Truck: Rocky Road
------------------------------------------------------------
✅ Reason 1: PASS (100%)

✅ Reason 2: PASS (95%)

✅ Reason 3: PASS (95%)


BOOK: Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's
------------------------------------------------------------
✅ Reason 1: PASS (100%)

✅ Reason 2: PASS (100%)

✅ Reason 3: PASS (95%)


SUMMARY: 9/9 reasons passed (100.0%)
OVERALL STATUS: PASS

Citation Validation Summary: 9/9 passed

PER-BOOK AI VALIDATION REPORT - Query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
================================================================================

OVERALL RELEVANCE SCORE: 70%
STATUS: FAIL
BOOKS ANALYZED: 3

BOOK 1: "The Antiracist Kid"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 85%

SECTION SCORES:
  Author Information: 100% - Author's name is complete, accurate, and relevant.
  Publishing Date: 100% - Publishing date is provided and is accurate.
  Why Match Explanations: 95% - The explanations clearly and effectively state why this book is suitable for children.
  Relevance Scores: 45% - The justification for the score is logically flawed. A specific topic like 'antiracism' does not make a children's book less relevant to a general query for 'children's books'.

DETAILED FEEDBACK:
  • This is an excellent and appropriate book suggestion for the query.
  • The core information (author, date, summary points) is presented well.
  • The primary weakness is the 'Gap' explanation, which incorrectly penalizes the book for having a specific theme, despite the user's query being very broad.

IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
  • Revise the scoring logic. For a general query, a specific sub-genre or topic that is still for the target audience should be considered a 100% match.
  • The 'Gap' should only be used if there's a genuine mismatch with the query's explicit or strongly implied constraints.

================================================================================

BOOK 2: "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 85%

SECTION SCORES:
  Author Information: 100% - Author's name is correct and completely provided.
  Publishing Date: 100% - The publishing date is accurate and included.
  Why Match Explanations: 95% - The reasons provided are excellent, highlighting its suitability for early readers and its visual appeal.
  Relevance Scores: 45% - The justification for the score is poor and follows the same flawed logic as the first book. A focus on 'trucks and reading skills' makes it a perfect children's book, not a less relevant one.

DETAILED FEEDBACK:
  • This is a very suitable book choice for children, especially early readers.
  • The 'Why Match' section effectively communicates the book's value to the target audience.
  • The justification for the 95% score is illogical. The book's specific theme and format are strengths, not gaps in relevance, for this query.

IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
  • The scoring model should recognize that specific themes (like vehicles) and formats (like 'I Can Read') are features that fulfill the query for 'children's books', not detract from it.

================================================================================

BOOK 3: "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 40%

SECTION SCORES:
  Author Information: 10% - The author's name is truncated ('Jane ...'), making the information incomplete.
  Publishing Date: 0% - The publishing date is missing entirely due to the response being truncated.
  Why Match Explanations: 90% - Despite the truncation, the provided 'Why Match' reasons are strong and relevant.
  Relevance Scores: 40% - The justification repeats the same logical flaw as the other two books, and the overall entry is incomplete, which undermines the score's credibility.

DETAILED FEEDBACK:
  • The book itself is a relevant choice, but the response is incomplete.
  • Critical information like the full author name and publishing date is missing because the text was cut off.
  • The 'Gap' explanation is consistent with the flawed logic seen in the other recommendations.

IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
  • Ensure that the full response is generated and not truncated, as this leads to missing critical information.
  • Fix the systemic issue in the relevance score justification.

================================================================================

SUMMARY FEEDBACK:
----------------------------------------
• The response successfully identified three appropriate books that match the user's broad query.
• The 'Why this is a match' explanations are generally high-quality and informative.
• There is a critical and repeated logical error in how the 'Relevance Scores' are justified; the model penalizes books for having specific themes, which is incorrect for a general query.
• The response was truncated, rendering the third book recommendation incomplete and significantly reducing its quality.

OVERALL IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
----------------------------------------
• The top priority is to fix the model's logic for justifying relevance scores. A book's specific topic does not make it less of a 'children's book'.
• Resolve any technical issues that cause responses to be truncated, as this omits essential data.
• The model could improve by offering more variety in its selections (e.g., picture book, chapter book, non-fiction) to better cover the broadness of the query.

=== SCENARIO LOGS: Book Genie Response Validation with Citation Verification ===
[2:44:04 PM] Navigating to Creative Workspace login page
[2:44:07 PM] Homepage visibility: false
[2:44:07 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[2:44:07 PM] ℹ️ Preparing to type query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[2:44:07 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for chat input to be visible
[2:44:08 PM] ℹ️ Clearing chat input
[2:44:08 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[2:44:09 PM] ℹ️ Pressing Enter to submit query
[2:44:10 PM] ✅ Query submitted successfully: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[2:44:10 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for AI to complete thinking...
[2:44:10 PM] 📋 WAITING FOR AI RESPONSE
[2:44:10 PM] ℹ️ Looking for AI thinking indicator...
[2:44:10 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to appear (max 2 minutes)
[2:44:12 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking indicator appeared - AI is processing the request
[2:44:12 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to disappear (max 5 minutes)
[2:44:22 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking completed - Response should be ready
[2:44:22 PM] ℹ️ Allowing additional time for response rendering
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ AI response wait process completed
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Validating response for query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[2:44:25 PM] 📋 VALIDATING RESPONSE FOR QUERY: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Locating the latest response in chat
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for response to be visible (max 30 seconds)
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ Response received - Length: 2651 characters
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Response preview: Watch Me WorkInterpreting context for your query...Retrieving Relevant Books for 'books for children...
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Extracting book data from response...
[2:44:25 PM] 📋 EXTRACTING BOOK DATA FROM RESPONSE
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Locating BookGenie response container
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from response
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ HTML content extracted - Length: 26992 characters
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract book data
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED 3 BOOKS
[2:44:25 PM] 📋 EXTRACTED BOOKS SUMMARY
[2:44:25 PM] 📚 1. "The Antiracist Kid" - Score: 98%%
[2:44:25 PM] 📚 2. "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road" - Score: 95%%
[2:44:25 PM] 📚 3. "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's" - Score: 93%%
[2:44:25 PM] 📊 Total books extracted: 3
[2:44:25 PM] 📊 Average relevance score: 95%
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ Extracted 3 books from response
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Saving 3 books to Excel file: test_results/suggest_3_books_for_childrens.xlsx
[2:44:25 PM] 📋 SAVING BOOKS TO EXCEL FILE
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Target file path: test_results/suggest_3_books_for_childrens.xlsx
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Exporting 3 books to Excel format
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ Book data saved to: test_results/suggest_3_books_for_childrens.xlsx
[2:44:25 PM] 📊 File verified - Size: 17.83 KB
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ ✓ Excel file creation verified successfully
[2:44:25 PM] 📋 STARTING INDIVIDUAL BOOK VALIDATION (3 books) for query: "Suggest 3 books for childrens"
[2:44:25 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 1: "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "The Antiracist Kid" vs expected: "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 98% vs expected: 98%
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 98% (expected 98%)
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 3 vs expected 3
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 3 points (expected 3)
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 1 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Book 1 validation completed
[2:44:25 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 2: "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road" vs expected: "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 95% vs expected: 95%
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 95% (expected 95%)
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 3 vs expected 3
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 3 points (expected 3)
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 2 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Book 2 validation completed
[2:44:25 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 3: "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's" vs expected: "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 93% vs expected: 93%
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 93% (expected 93%)
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 3 vs expected 3
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 3 points (expected 3)
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 3 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Book 3 validation completed
[2:44:25 PM] 📊 VALIDATION SUMMARY: 3/3 books passed
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ ALL BOOKS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY!
[2:44:25 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING REASON-CITATION MATCHES
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Starting citation validation process...
[2:44:25 PM] 📋 🚀 STARTING COMPLETE CITATION VALIDATION WORKFLOW
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Step 1: Extracting books from AI response
[2:44:25 PM] 📋 EXTRACTING BOOK DATA FROM RESPONSE
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Locating BookGenie response container
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from response
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ HTML content extracted - Length: 26992 characters
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract book data
[2:44:25 PM] ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED 3 BOOKS
[2:44:25 PM] 📋 EXTRACTED BOOKS SUMMARY
[2:44:25 PM] 📚 1. "The Antiracist Kid" - Score: 98%%
[2:44:25 PM] 📚 2. "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road" - Score: 95%%
[2:44:25 PM] 📚 3. "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's" - Score: 93%%
[2:44:25 PM] 📊 Total books extracted: 3
[2:44:25 PM] 📊 Average relevance score: 95%
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Step 2: Extracting citation texts from book elements
[2:44:25 PM] 📋 📚 EXTRACTING CITATION TEXTS FROM BOOK ELEMENTS
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Step 1: Waiting for main book section
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Found 10 total accordion sections
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "1. The Antiracist Kid"
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "2. Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "3. Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Processing 3 individual book sections
[2:44:25 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 1: "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:44:25 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:44:28 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:44:28 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:44:31 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:44:31 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 citation buttons for "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:44:31 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/3 for "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:44:31 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 1 for "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:44:32 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 1
[2:44:34 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): young readers...
[2:44:34 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 1
[2:44:36 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 1 closed successfully
[2:44:36 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 13)
[2:44:36 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/3 for "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:44:36 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 2 for "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:44:37 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 2
[2:44:39 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Ruby, Shawn, and Dani...
[2:44:39 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 2
[2:44:40 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 2 closed successfully
[2:44:40 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 21)
[2:44:40 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/3 for "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:44:40 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 3 for "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:44:41 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 3
[2:44:43 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Identity, Justice, and Activism...
[2:44:43 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 3
[2:44:45 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 3 closed successfully
[2:44:45 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 31)
[2:44:45 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:44:46 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:44:46 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "The Antiracist Kid" - 3 citations extracted
[2:44:46 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 2: "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:44:46 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:44:49 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:44:49 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:44:53 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:44:53 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 citation buttons for "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:44:53 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/3 for "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:44:53 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 1 for "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:44:54 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 1
[2:44:56 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): as an "I Can Read Book,...
[2:44:56 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 1
[2:44:57 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 1 closed successfully
[2:44:57 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 23)
[2:44:57 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/3 for "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:44:57 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 2 for "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:44:58 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 2
[2:45:00 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): featuring full-color art...
[2:45:00 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 2
[2:45:02 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 2 closed successfully
[2:45:02 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 24)
[2:45:02 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/3 for "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:45:02 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 3 for "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:45:03 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 3
[2:45:05 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Axel is a little truck with great big wheels...
[2:45:05 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 3
[2:45:06 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 3 closed successfully
[2:45:06 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 44)
[2:45:06 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:45:08 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:45:08 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road" - 3 citations extracted
[2:45:08 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 3: "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:45:08 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:45:11 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:45:11 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:45:14 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:45:14 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 citation buttons for "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:45:14 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/3 for "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:45:14 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 1 for "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:45:15 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 1
[2:45:17 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Fancy Nancy I Can Read series...
[2:45:17 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 1
[2:45:19 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 1 closed successfully
[2:45:19 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 29)
[2:45:19 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/3 for "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:45:19 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 2 for "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:45:20 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 2
[2:45:22 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): children learning to sound out words and sentences...
[2:45:22 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 2
[2:45:23 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 2 closed successfully
[2:45:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 50)
[2:45:23 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/3 for "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:45:23 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 3 for "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:45:24 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 3
[2:45:26 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Join Nancy in this comical and endearing addition to the Fancy Nancy...
[2:45:26 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 3
[2:45:28 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 3 closed successfully
[2:45:28 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 68)
[2:45:28 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:45:29 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:45:29 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's" - 3 citations extracted
[2:45:29 PM] ✅ 🎉 Successfully extracted citations from 3 books
[2:45:29 PM] ℹ️ Step 3: Validating reason-citation matches
[2:45:29 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING REASON-CITATION MATCHES (80% THRESHOLD)
[2:45:29 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 3 reasons for: "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:45:29 PM] ℹ️    Reason 1: Checking match...
[2:45:29 PM] ✅    ✅ "The Antiracist Kid" - Reason 1: 100% match - PASS
[2:45:29 PM] ℹ️    Reason 2: Checking match...
[2:45:29 PM] ✅    ✅ "The Antiracist Kid" - Reason 2: 100% match - PASS
[2:45:29 PM] ℹ️    Reason 3: Checking match...
[2:45:29 PM] ✅    ✅ "The Antiracist Kid" - Reason 3: 100% match - PASS
[2:45:29 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 3 reasons for: "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:45:29 PM] ℹ️    Reason 1: Checking match...
[2:45:29 PM] ✅    ✅ "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road" - Reason 1: 100% match - PASS
[2:45:29 PM] ℹ️    Reason 2: Checking match...
[2:45:43 PM] ✅    ✅ "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road" - Reason 2: 95% match - PASS
[2:45:43 PM] ℹ️    Reason 3: Checking match...
[2:45:56 PM] ✅    ✅ "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road" - Reason 3: 95% match - PASS
[2:45:56 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 3 reasons for: "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:45:56 PM] ℹ️    Reason 1: Checking match...
[2:45:56 PM] ✅    ✅ "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's" - Reason 1: 100% match - PASS
[2:45:56 PM] ℹ️    Reason 2: Checking match...
[2:45:56 PM] ✅    ✅ "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's" - Reason 2: 100% match - PASS
[2:45:56 PM] ℹ️    Reason 3: Checking match...
[2:46:07 PM] ✅    ✅ "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's" - Reason 3: 95% match - PASS
[2:46:07 PM] 📊 📊 CITATION VALIDATION SUMMARY: 9/9 passed (100.0%)
[2:46:07 PM] ✅ 🎉 REASON-CITATION VALIDATION: OVERALL PASSED
[2:46:07 PM] ℹ️ Step 4: Generating detailed report
[2:46:07 PM] 📋 📋 GENERATING CITATION VALIDATION REPORT
[2:46:07 PM] ℹ️ Report generated: 9/9 reasons passed
[2:46:07 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation workflow completed successfully
[2:46:07 PM] 📊 📈 OVERALL CITATION VALIDATION: 9/9 (100.0%)
[2:46:07 PM] ✅ ✅ REASON-CITATION VALIDATION: OVERALL PASSED
[2:46:07 PM] 📋 📋 GENERATING DETAILED CITATION VALIDATION REPORT
[2:46:07 PM] ℹ️ Generating HTML citation validation report
[2:46:07 PM] ✅ Generated HTML report for 9 reasons
[2:46:07 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation HTML report generated and attached
[2:46:07 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation plain text report attached
[2:46:07 PM] ℹ️ Checking database connectivity...
[2:46:07 PM] ✅ ✅ Database connected successfully
[2:46:07 PM] ℹ️ Database path: /home/runner/work/HC_Epub_Automation/HC_Epub_Automation/tests/test_data/database.xlsx
[2:46:07 PM] ℹ️ Total books: 5455
[2:46:07 PM] 📊 Database contains 5455 books
[2:46:07 PM] ✅ ✅ Database book count requirement met: 5455 >= 2020
[2:46:07 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING EXTRACTED BOOKS INDIVIDUALLY AGAINST DATABASE
[2:46:07 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 1/3: "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:46:07 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "The Antiracist Kid"
[2:46:07 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "The Antiracist Kid" → "He"
[2:46:07 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 2/3: "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:46:07 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road"
[2:46:08 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road" → "He"
[2:46:08 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 3/3: "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:46:08 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's"
[2:46:08 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's" → "Nancy"
[2:46:08 PM] 📊 INDIVIDUAL DATABASE VALIDATION SUMMARY: 3/3 books found in database
[2:46:08 PM] ✅ 🎉 ALL BOOKS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY AGAINST DATABASE!
[2:46:08 PM] 📋 🤖 VALIDATING RESPONSE RELEVANCE WITH GEMINI AI - PER BOOK ANALYSIS
[2:46:08 PM] ℹ️ Starting Gemini AI per-book relevance validation...
[2:46:08 PM] 📋 🤖 ANALYZING RESPONSE RELEVANCE WITH GEMINI AI - PER BOOK ANALYSIS
[2:46:08 PM] ℹ️ Starting Gemini AI analysis with retry logic...
[2:46:53 PM] 📊 Gemini AI Overall Relevance Score: 70%
[2:46:53 PM] 📊 Analyzed 3 books individually
[2:46:53 PM] ❌ ❌ GEMINI VALIDATION: Response relevance below threshold (70%)
[2:46:53 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "The Antiracist Kid" - Score: 85%
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Author Information: 100% - Author's name is complete, accurate, and relevant.
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Publishing Date: 100% - Publishing date is provided and is accurate.
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 95% - The explanations clearly and effectively state why this book is suitable for children.
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Relevance Scores: 45% - The justification for the score is logically flawed. A specific topic like 'antiracism' does not make a children's book less relevant to a general query for 'children's books'.
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️    - Revise the scoring logic. For a general query, a specific sub-genre or topic that is still for the target audience should be considered a 100% match.
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️    - The 'Gap' should only be used if there's a genuine mismatch with the query's explicit or strongly implied constraints.
[2:46:53 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "Axel the Truck: Rocky Road" - Score: 85%
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Author Information: 100% - Author's name is correct and completely provided.
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Publishing Date: 100% - The publishing date is accurate and included.
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 95% - The reasons provided are excellent, highlighting its suitability for early readers and its visual appeal.
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Relevance Scores: 45% - The justification for the score is poor and follows the same flawed logic as the first book. A focus on 'trucks and reading skills' makes it a perfect children's book, not a less relevant one.
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️    - The scoring model should recognize that specific themes (like vehicles) and formats (like 'I Can Read') are features that fulfill the query for 'children's books', not detract from it.
[2:46:53 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "Fancy Nancy: Hair Dos and Hair Dont's" - Score: 40%
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Author Information: 10% - The author's name is truncated ('Jane ...'), making the information incomplete.
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Publishing Date: 0% - The publishing date is missing entirely due to the response being truncated.
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 90% - Despite the truncation, the provided 'Why Match' reasons are strong and relevant.
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Relevance Scores: 40% - The justification repeats the same logical flaw as the other two books, and the overall entry is incomplete, which undermines the score's credibility.
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️    - Ensure that the full response is generated and not truncated, as this leads to missing critical information.
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️    - Fix the systemic issue in the relevance score justification.
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️ 📊 SUMMARY FEEDBACK:
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️    • The response successfully identified three appropriate books that match the user's broad query.
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️    • The 'Why this is a match' explanations are generally high-quality and informative.
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️    • There is a critical and repeated logical error in how the 'Relevance Scores' are justified; the model penalizes books for having specific themes, which is incorrect for a general query.
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️    • The response was truncated, rendering the third book recommendation incomplete and significantly reducing its quality.
[2:46:53 PM] ❌ ❌ GEMINI AI VALIDATION FAILED: 70% relevance score (required: 80%)
[2:46:53 PM] ℹ️ Continuing execution due to soft assertion...
=== END LOGS ===